Murder of Carlos Palomino

During the trial, which was attended as a private prosecution by the mother of Carlos Palomino and the young people who accompanied him, and Esteban Ibarra – leader of the Movement against Intolerance – as part of the popular prosecution,[3] the facts of murder were considered proven after viewing the video surveillance cameras. Also, Josué Estébanez was a right-wing extremist due to the fact that he was wearing a sweatshirt of a brand considered to be neo-Nazi symbolism, as well as gestures that could be observed in the said recording, such as the shout and greeting "Sieg Heil".[4][5] At all times, the accused tried to dissociate himself from the ultra movement,[6] despite the fact that various fascist and neo-Nazi associations openly showed their support for him.[7][8] The psychotic break and mental imbalance were also ruled out.[7] During the trial, Estébanez showed no remorse for the acts;[7] he only intervened on the last day of the trial to ask for forgiveness for what had happened.[9]

Tribute to Carlos Palomino by Rommy Arce, Celia Mayer, Maby Muñoz (Carlos' mother) and the Mothers against repression collective - 26990187395 (cropped)

The defence requested a prison sentence of six months for reckless homicide and three months for a crime of injury for the stabbing of a second person.[7] After two years of trial, the Provincial Court of Madrid sentenced Josué Estébanez to a total of 26 years in prison – 19 years for the crime of murder with the aggravating circumstance of ideological hatred and 7 years for attempted homicide,[10] plus compensation of 150,000 euros.[8] The family prosecution asked for 37 years in prison and compensation, while the Alto del Arenal residents' association and the Movement against Intolerance asked for 30 years for hate crime.[11] The sentence was confirmed in its entirety in cassation by the Second Chamber of the Supreme Court in its judgement 360/2010 of 22 April, making the conviction final.[12]

The murder of Carlos Palomino was the most publicised neo-Nazi hate crime of the first decade of the 21st century in Spain. It was also the first time that the Spanish judiciary applied the aggravating factor of ideological motives in a conviction.[4][7][8]

After Palomino's death, his mother, Mavi Muñoz, became an anti-fascist activist. She founded the Association of Victims of Fascist, Racist and Homophobic Violence, to fight against fascist violence and demand the outlawing of these groups,[4] [13] and is a member of the association Mothers Against Repression[8] of which she is honorary president.[14]

Anti-fascist collectives placed plaques on up to four occasions at the Metro stations where Carlos Palomino had died, but they were always vandalised.[15] In 2016, Madrid City Council placed a plaque at number 145 Paseo de las Delicias,[16] where Palomino was murdered.[17]

The plaque reads

"Aquí fue asesinado el 11 de noviembre de 2007 Carlos Javier Palomino Muñoz a la edad de 16 años, luchador contra el fascismo y el racismo"[17]

Zaragoza fountains dyed red in homage to Carlos Palomino (2008).

Every 11 November, various anti-fascist groups organise demonstrations to pay tribute to Carlos Palomino, 2021222324 who has become a symbol of their struggle.[18][19] In 2017, the tenth anniversary of the crime, a demonstration was organised in Madrid, attended by around a thousand people.[20] On that date, protest actions were also held in other Spanish cities. As a memorial, the water in various fountains is often dyed red during demonstrations.[21]

A brigade of Spaniards, in imitation of the International Brigades, went to the conflict in Ukraine in 2014, forming the Carlos Palomino Brigade.[22]