Top Chess Engine Championship
Top Chess Engine Championship, formerly known as Thoresen Chess Engines Competition (TCEC or nTCEC), is a computer chess tournament that has been run since 2010. It was organized, directed, and hosted by Martin Thoresen until the end of Season 6; from Season 7 onward it has been organized by Chessdom. It is often regarded as the Unofficial World Computer Chess Championship because of its strong participant line-up and long time-control matches on high-end hardware, giving rise to very high-class chess.[1][2]
After a short break in 2012,[3] TCEC was restarted in early 2013 (as nTCEC)[4] and is currently active (renamed as TCEC in early 2014) with 24/7 live broadcasts of chess matches on its website.
Since season 5, TCEC has been sponsored by Chessdom Arena.[5][6] The current TCEC champion is Stockfish 14, which defeated LCZero 0.28 56-44 in the TCEC Season 21 Superfinal 100-game match, which took place June 20 - August 7, 2021.
Overview
Basic structure of competition
The TCEC competition is divided into seasons, where each season happens over a course of a few months, with matches played round-the-clock and broadcast live over the internet. Each season is divided into several qualifying stages and one "superfinal", where the top two chess engines play 100 games to win the title of "TCEC Grand Champion". In the superfinal, each engine plays 50 openings, once as each side. Beginning in Season 11 in 2018, a division system was introduced, and beginning in season 21 in 2021, the season was expanded to include a Cup, a Swiss tournament, and a Fischer Random Chess tournament.
Engine settings/characteristics
Pondering is set to off. All engines run on mostly the same hardware[7] and use the same opening book, which is set by the organizers and changed in every stage. Large pages are disabled, but access to various endgame tablebases is permitted. Engines are allowed updates between stages; if there is a critical play-limiting bug, they are also allowed to be updated once during the stage. In previous seasons, if an engine crashes 3 times in one event, it is disqualified to avoid distorting the results for the other engines; however starting in TCEC Season 20, an engine is allowed to crash as many times as possible without being disqualified from the current event; however, the engine will still be disqualified from future events unless the crash is fixed.[8] TCEC generates an Elo rating list from the matches played during the tournament. An initial rating is given to any new participant based on its rating in other chess engine rating lists.
Criteria for entering the competition
There is no definite criterion for entering into the competition, other than inviting the top participants under active development from various rating lists which can run on their Windows platform. Initially, the list of participants was personally chosen by Thoresen before the start of a season. His stated goal was to include "every major engine that is not a direct clone".[9] Usually chess engines that support multiprocessor mode are preferred (8-cores or higher), and engines in active development are given preference. Since TCEC 12, engines like LCZero which use GPUs for neural processing were supported. Either Winboard or UCI protocol are required to participate.
The tournament has attracted nearly all the top competitors compared to the World Computer Chess Championship, but Shredder's developers have declined to enter it in the competition. Also absent are former WCCC champions Rybka, Junior, HIARCS, and Zappa. In TCEC 20, Houdini, Fire, Rybka (engine in Fritz up to TCEC 16), and Critter were banned due to allegations of plagiarism.
Structure by event
Original format
| Season number | Structure |
|---|---|
| Pre TCEC | 3 matches followed by 2 tournaments then alternating between match and tournament until there were 6 tournaments and 5 matches |
| 1 | 3 division (1 through 3) followed by elite match |
| 2 | Same as Season 1 but with 6 divisions (A through F) |
| 3 | 2 stages (1 followed by 2a). Season not completed. |
| 4 | Same as Season 3 but with 4 more tournaments (Stages 2b, 3 and 4 followed by a superfinal, in that order) |
| 5 | 4 stages (1 through 4) followed by a superfinal |
| 6 | Same as Season 5 but stage 1 was stage 1a through c and a Chess960 tournament after the superfinal |
| 7 | Same as Season 6 but no stage 1c nor tournament after the superfinal |
| 8 | Same as Season 7 but no stage 4 |
| 9 | Same as Season 8 but between the stage tournaments and superfinal was a rapid tournament |
| 10 | 2 stages (1 followed by 2) then superfinal then 2 other tournaments (rapid followed by blitz) |
League format
| Season number | Structure |
|---|---|
| 11 - 14 | 5 divisions (labelled 4, 3, 2, 1, and Premier) of 8 engines each. Top 2 of each division promote, bottom 2 relegate; top 2 of Premier play the superfinal. Seasons 13 and 14 also had a cup, which were a 5-round single elimination tournament.[10] |
| 15 | |
| 16 | |
| 17 | |
| 18 | |
| 19 | |
| 20 | 1 division (labelled Qualification) with a variable number of engines, and 5 divisions (labelled 4, 3, 2, 1, and Premier) of 8 engines each. Top 2 of each division promote, bottom 2 relegate; top 2 of Premier play the superfinal. |
| 21 | Starting this season, each season consists of a league format, the Cup, a Fischer Random Chess tournament, and a Swiss tournament.[11] |
TCEC Cups
| Event | Structure |
|---|---|
| TCEC Cup 1 | Knockout tournament, with 8-game Rapid matches and tiebreaks if necessary. |
| TCEC Cup 2 | Same as Cup 1 |
| TCEC Cup 3 | Same as Cups 1 and 2 |
| TCEC Cup 4 | Same as Cups 1, 2, and 3 |
| TCEC Cup 5 | Knockout tournament, with 4-game Rapid matches and tiebreaks if necessary. |
| TCEC Cup 6 | Same as Cup 5 |
| TCEC Cup 7 | Same as Cups 5 and 6 |
| TCEC Cup 8 | Same as Cups 5, 6, and 7 |
| TCEC Cup 9 | Same as Cups 5, 6, 7, and 8 |
TCEC Swiss
| Event | Structure |
|---|---|
| TCEC Swiss 1 | Swiss-system tournament with 38 competing engines, playing 11 rounds of game pairs, for a total of 418 games. |
| TCEC Swiss 2 | Swiss-system tournament with 44 competing engines, playing 11 rounds of game pairs, for a total of 484 games. |
TCEC FRC
| Event | Structure |
|---|---|
| TCEC Season 6 FRC | Quad-round-robin tournament consisting of the top 8 engines that had support for Fischer Random Chess. |
| TCEC FRC 1 | |
| TCEC FRC 2 | |
| TCEC FRC 3 | |
| TCEC FRC 4 | |
Event results
Main event
The tables display the results of the events that have the elite match/superfinal.
Original format
| Season | Date | Winner | ver | Runner-Up | ver | Elite match/Superfinal score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TCEC Season 1 | Dec 2010 – Feb 2011 | Houdini | 1.5a | Rybka | 4.0 | + 12 = 23 - 5 |
| TCEC Season 2 | Feb – Apr 2011 | Houdini | 1.5a | Rybka | 4.1 | + 9 = 26 - 5 |
| TCEC Season 3 | Apr – May 2011 | N/A (season not completed) | ||||
| TCEC Season 41 | Jan – May 2013 | Houdini | 3 | Stockfish | 250413 | + 6 = 38 - 4 |
| TCEC Season 52 | Aug – Dec 2013 | Komodo | 1142 | Stockfish | 191113 | + 10 = 30 - 8 |
| TCEC Season 6 | Feb – May 2014 | Stockfish | 170514 | Komodo | 7x | + 13 = 45 - 6 |
| TCEC Season 73 | Sep – Dec 2014 | Komodo | 1333 | Stockfish | 141214 | + 7 = 53 - 4 |
| TCEC Season 8 | Aug – Nov 2015 | Komodo | 9.3x | Stockfish | 021115 | + 9 = 89 - 2 |
| TCEC Season 9 | May – Dec 2016 | Stockfish | 8 | Houdini | 5 | + 17 = 75 - 8 |
| TCEC Season 10 | Oct – Dec 2017 | Houdini | 6.03 | Komodo | 1970.00 | + 15 = 76 - 9 |
- 1 Originally named "nTCEC Season 1".
- 2 Originally named "nTCEC Season 2".
- 3 Season 7 did not use endgame table bases at all and Stage two did not use opening books either.
League format
After season 20, this event is called the Leagues, as each season also includes the Swiss, the Cup, and the FRC tournament.[12]
| Season | Date | Winner | version | Runner-Up | version | Superfinal score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TCEC Season 11 | Jan 2018 – Apr 2018 | Stockfish | 260318 | Houdini | 6.03 | + 20 = 78 - 2 |
| TCEC Season 12 | Apr 2018 – Jul 2018 | Stockfish | 180614 | Komodo | 12.1.1 | + 29 = 62 - 9 |
| TCEC Season 13 | Aug 2018 – Nov 2018 | Stockfish | 18102108 | Komodo | 2155.00 | + 16 = 78 - 6 |
| TCEC Season 14 | Nov 2018 – Feb 2019 | Stockfish | 190203 | LCZero | v0.20.2-32930 | + 10 = 81 - 9 |
| TCEC Season 15 | Mar 2019 – May 2019 | LCZero | v0.21.1-nT40.T8.610 | Stockfish | 19050918 | + 14 = 79 - 7 |
| TCEC Season 16 | Jul 2019 – Oct 2019 | Stockfish | 19092522 | AllieStein | v0.5-dev_7b41f8c-n11 | + 14 = 81 - 5 |
| TCEC Season 17 | Jan 2020 – Apr 2020 | LCZero | v0.24-sv-t60-3010 | Stockfish | 20200407 | + 17 = 71 - 12 |
| TCEC Season 18 | May 2020 – Jul 2020 | Stockfish | 202006170741 | LCZero | v0.25.1-svjio-t60-3972-mlh | + 23 = 61 - 16 |
| TCEC Season 19 | Aug 2020 – Oct 2020 | Stockfish | 202009282242_nn-baeb9ef2d183 | LCZero | v0.26.3-rc1_T60.SV.JH.92-190 | + 18 = 73 - 9 |
| TCEC Season 20 | Dec 2020 – Feb 2021 | Stockfish | 20210113 | LCZero | 0.27.0d-Tilps-dje-magic_JH.94-100 | + 14 = 78 - 8 |
| TCEC Season 21 Leagues | May 2021 – Aug 2021 | Stockfish | 14_202107131735 | LCZero | 0.28-dev+_69626 | + 19 = 74 - 7 |
TCEC Cups
| Season | Date | Winner | Runner-Up |
|---|---|---|---|
| TCEC Cup 1 | Oct 2018 | Stockfish 270918 | Houdini 6.03 |
| TCEC Cup 2 | Jan 2019 | LCZero v0.20.1-32742 | Houdini 6.03 |
| TCEC Cup 3 | May 2019 | LCZero v0.21.1-nT40.T6.532 | Stockfish 19042711 |
| TCEC Cup 4 | Oct 2019 | Stockfish 19100908 | LCZero v0.22.0-nT2 |
| TCEC Cup 5 | Apr 2020 | Stockfish 202004181536 | LCZero v0.24-sv-t60-3010 |
| TCEC Cup 6 | Jul 2020 | AllieStein v0.7_dev2-net_15.0 | LCZero v0.26.0_sv-t60-4229-mlh_opt2 |
| TCEC Cup 7 | Nov 2020 | Stockfish 2020102823_nn-2eb2e0707c2b | LCZero v0.26.3_T60.SV.JH.92-270 |
| TCEC Cup 8 | Feb 2021 | Stockfish 202102202249 | LCZero 0.27.0-pr1509_JH.94-100 |
| TCEC Cup 9 | Oct 2021 | Stockfish dev15_20211015 | LCZero 0.28-dev+_609958 |
TCEC Swiss
| Season | Date | Winner | Runner-Up |
|---|---|---|---|
| TCEC Swiss 1 | Apr 2021 | KomodoDragon 2679.08 | Stockfish 20210310 |
| TCEC Swiss 2 | Nov – Dec 2021 | Dragon 2.5.1 | Stockfish 14.1_20211101 |
TCEC FRC
| Season | Date | Winner | Runner-Up |
|---|---|---|---|
| TCEC Season 6 FRC | Jun – Jul 2014 | Stockfish 260614 | Houdini 4 |
| TCEC FRC 1 | Oct – Nov 2019 | Stockfish 191107 | AllieStein v0.5_c328142-n11.1 |
| TCEC FRC 2 | Nov 2020 | Stockfish 202011101829_nn-c3ca321c51c9 | LCZero v0.26.3_T60.SV.JH.92-330 |
| TCEC FRC 3 | Mar 2021 | KomodoDragon 2671.00 | Stockfish 20210226 |
| TCEC FRC 4 | Dec 2021 |
Other TCEC events
| Season | Date | Winner | Runner-Up |
|---|---|---|---|
| TCEC Season 9 Rapid1 | Sep 2016 | Houdini 200716 | Komodo 1692.19 |
| TCEC Season 10 Rapid | Dec 2017 | Stockfish 051117 | Houdini 6.03 |
| TCEC Season 10 Blitz | Dec 2017 | Komodo 1959.00 | Stockfish 051117 |
- 1 Double round robin tournament.
Statistics
All-time table for champions after TCEC Season 20
This table includes Main/Leagues, Cup, FRC and Swiss results.[13]
| Rank | Engine | Participations | Games | W | D | L | W (%) | D (%) | L (%) | Pts | Avg Pts | Finals | Trophies |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Stockfish | 32 | 3013 | 797 | 2015 | 201 | 26.45 | 66.88 | 6.67 | 1804.5 | 0.599 | 25 | 17 |
| 2 | Komodo | 32 | 2553 | 626 | 1676 | 251 | 24.52 | 65.65 | 9.83 | 1464 | 0.573 | 9 | 5 |
| 3 | LCZero | 20 | 1561 | 350 | 1059 | 152 | 22.42 | 67.84 | 9.74 | 879.5 | 0.563 | 14 | 4 |
Notable games
| Season number | Date and game title info | White | Black | Result | Notes (material calculations excluding king) | Source/s |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 28 January 2011 (Elite Match, Round 1 of Game 1) | Rybka | Houdini | 0-1 | Houdini sacrifices three pawns for piece activity and defeats the reigning computer chess champion Rybka in this game, popularly dubbed as the "Houdini Immortal". | [17][18] |
| 4 | 25 March 2013 (Stage 2b, Game 3 of Round 14) | Shredder | Gull | 1/2-1/2 | Shredder, on the brink of being checkmated, pulls off a miraculous escape. | [14][15][16] |
| 15 | May 21, 2019 (Game 61 of Superfinal) | Stockfish | Leela Chess Zero | 0-1 | [19] | |
| 16 | September 28, 2019 (Game 14 of Superfinal) | Stockfish | AllieStein | 1-0 | [20] | |
| 17 | April 8, 2020 (Game 1 of Superfinal) | Stockfish | Leela Chess Zero | 1/2-1/2 | Although a draw, there was a moment in the game beginning around move 14 that stunned the commentary team at chess24 consisting of GMs Jan Gustafsson, Laurent Fressinet, Peter Heine Nielsen, and Anish Giri. | [21] |
| April 8, 2020 (Game 3 of Superfinal) | Stockfish | Leela Chess Zero | 1-0 | The engines played a Scheveningen Sicilian, and Peter Heine Nielsen, coach to Magnus Carlsen, is simply amazed that the position is simply won for white. White manages to place a pawn on h6 and exploits the resulting weaknesses in black's kingside position, where the black king is located, resulting in a win for white. | [21] | |
| April 9, 2020 (Game 6 of Superfinal) | Leela Chess Zero | Stockfish | 1/2-1/2 | The engines played the Mar del Plata variation of the King's Indian Defence, entering a critical variation known to opening theorists, and despite white's advantage, Stockfish was able to find an exceptional defense and draw the game. | [21] | |
| April 10, 2020 (Game 14 of Superfinal) | Leela Chess Zero | Stockfish | 1-0 | Leela sacrifices a pawn to open its bishop and dominate Stockfish on the dark squares. However, it then exchanges off the dark squared bishop, which shocked the commentary team at chess24, and still won the game. | [21] | |
| 18 | June 20, 2020 (Game 8 of Superfinal) | Stockfish | Leela Chess Zero | 1-0 | [22] | |
| 19 | October 9, 2020 (Game 60 of Superfinal) | Stockfish | Leela Chess Zero | 1-0 | [23] | |
| 20 | January 21, 2021 (Game 33 of Superfinal) | Stockfish | Leela Chess Zero | 1-0 | [24] |
References
- Kosteniuk, Alexandra (August 15, 2013). "TCEC Computer Chess Championship New Season starts August 26th". Chess News Blog. Archived from the original on October 25, 2013. Retrieved October 25, 2013.
- Soltis, Andy (June 9, 2013). "Engine Super Bowl". New York Post. Retrieved October 25, 2013.
- Thoresen, Martin (May 28, 2011). "TCEC announcement: End of project". Talkchess. Archived from the original on October 25, 2013. Retrieved October 25, 2013.
- Thoresen, Martin (January 12, 2013). "Official (re)launch of TCEC - website is up!". Talkchess. Archived from the original on October 25, 2013. Retrieved October 25, 2013.
- Thoresen, Martin (August 15, 2013). "TCEC and Chessdom announces partnership". TCEC. Archived from the original on October 12, 2013. Retrieved October 25, 2013.
- "TCEC computer chess championship New Season starts August 26th". Chessdom. Chessdom. August 15, 2013. Retrieved October 25, 2013.
- Until season 13, all engines ran on the same hardware; however, in season 13 the entrance of two neural network engines caused TCEC to use different hardware for the two types of engines. "TCEC Season 13 – the advance of the NNs". Chessdom. 2 August 2018.
- "TCEC Leagues Season Rules, 15.Crashes".
- Chabris, Christopher. "Martin Thoresen's World Chess Championship".
- "Announcing TCEC Cup 2018 | Chessdom".
- "TCEC Leagues Season 21".
- "TCEC wiki".
- "TCEC - Live Chess Broadcast". www.tcec-chess.com.
- "Shredder (Computer) vs Gull (Computer) (2013) UnBb3vable!". www.chessgames.com.
- "Shredder - Gull, Stage 2b: Stupendous Stalemate Swindle". Archived from the original on 25 October 2013. Retrieved 25 October 2013.
- "A defensive brilliancy". Archived from the original on 28 October 2013. Retrieved 27 October 2013.
- "Rybka (Computer) vs Houdini (Computer) (2011) The Amazing Houdini". www.chessgames.com.
- Annotated by FM Dennis Monokroussos at TCEC
- Sadler, Matthew, The TCEC15 Computer Chess Superfinal: a perspective (PDF), retrieved 11 November 2021
- Sadler, Matthew, The TCEC16 Computer Chess Superfinal: a perspective (PDF), retrieved 11 November 2021
- Sadler, Matthew, The TCEC17 Computer Chess Superfinal: a perspective (PDF), retrieved 11 November 2021
- Sadler, Matthew, The TCEC18 Computer Chess Superfinal: a perspective (PDF), retrieved 11 November 2021
- Sadler, Matthew, The TCEC19 Computer Chess Superfinal: a perspective (PDF), retrieved 11 November 2021
- Sadler, Matthew, The TCEC20 Computer Chess Superfinal: a perspective (PDF), retrieved 11 November 2021
Sources
- "TCEC Season 8 – complete information". chessdom.com. August 18, 2015. Retrieved October 9, 2015.
- Perez-Franco, Roberto (January 15, 2014). "DIGITAL CHESS REVIEW: One chess champion per laptop". The Tech. 133 (62). Retrieved February 2, 2014.
External links
- TCEC Live Games Page
- TCEC Season 12 report, by Guy Haworth and Nelson Hernandez
- TCEC Season 13 report, by Guy Haworth and Nelson Hernandez
- Hernandez, Nelson; Haworth, Guy (October 2019). "TCEC15: The 15th Top Chess Engine Championship" (PDF). ICGA Journal. 41 (314): 153–163. doi:10.3233/ICG-190115. S2CID 208643228.
- Top Chess Engine Championship on Facebook
- TCEC games archive
- Additional information for Season 4
- Additional information for Season 5
- chessdom.org with an overview of TCEC's websites
